Index Ventures – The Founder’s Guide to Stock Options
Here is a summary of the guide’s introduction, including key findings:
Go to https://www.indexventures.com/rewarding-talent/
Our Insight – Why Index Wrote 'Rewarding Talent'
Index Ventures sees broad-based employee ownership as the missing catalyst for Europe to create its own Google‑ or Amazon‑scale companies. Silicon Valley’s deep option culture helps tiny start‑ups hire world‑class talent early, but Europe lacks a clear playbook and must navigate 30 different legal and tax regimes. The handbook therefore sets out practical guidance, benchmark data and real‑world case studies so European founders can design fair, competitive equity programmes from day one.
---
Our Take – A Call to Bring Employee Ownership to Europe
Competitive pressure is rising. U.S. start‑ups routinely grant options at every level and have produced thousands of employee millionaires, fuelling a virtuous cycle of talent and angel investment. European employees are starting to demand the same. Index argues that founders who move first on generous, transparent option plans will attract and retain the best people—but policy‑makers must also modernise national rules to remove tax and regulatory frictions.
---
The Methodology – How the Research Was Done
To ground its recommendations in evidence, Index combined multiple data sources:
| Cap‑table analysis | 73 European portfolio companies, sliced by funding round | Internal proprietary data |
| Option‑grant database | 4,000+ individual grants across 200+ EU & US start‑ups | Option Impact (Advanced HR) |
| Qualitative interviews | 27 founders/C‑suite leaders from seed to post‑IPO | Index portfolio network |
| ESOP practice survey | 53 European companies, >11,000 employees represented | Online survey |
| Legal & tax review | US plus key European & global markets | Taylor Wessing, Wilson Sonsini & other firms |
---
The first 'Rewarding Talent' (Dec 2017) quickly became a European “playbook.” This latest update:
* Adds seed‑stage equity advice and a new Elastic case study.
* Enriches guidance on retention grants and strategic advisers.
* Extends the country‑by‑country policy review from 12 to 24 jurisdictions.
* Sets out concrete recommendations for governments to foster option use.
---
Key Findings – What the Data Revealed
1. **Lower ownership:** Late‑stage European employees hold ~10 % of equity versus ~20 % in the U.S.
2. **Greater variance:** EU employee stakes range from 4 % – 20 %; U.S. levels are far more consistent.
3. **Divergent rules:** Terms on leavers and change‑of‑control differ sharply between regions.
4. **Executive bias:** Two‑thirds of EU options go to execs; in the U.S. it’s the reverse.
5. **Lagging expectations:** Many European hires still fail to ask for options—though this is changing.
6. **Benchmark gap:** Founders in Europe have lacked granular data on how much equity to grant.
7. **Tax disadvantage:** High strike prices and unfavourable tax make exercising costly in many EU states.
8. **Policy spread:** Estonia, the UK and France lead on supportive schemes; Germany notably lags.
9. **Tech intensity link:** Deep‑tech start‑ups allocate more ownership to staff than e‑commerce peers.
10. **Cash‑equity convergence:** Salaries are rising, but options remain critical for talent retention.
---
Stock Options 101 – A Primer for First‑Time Founders
An option grants the right, not the obligation, to buy shares at a fixed strike price—typically exercisable for up to 10 years and vesting over four years with a one‑year cliff. Exercising makes sense only if the current share price exceeds the strike.
In the U.S. options dominate because they require no upfront payment or tax at grant; Europe uses a patchwork of warrants, RSUs and “virtual” options, but the goal—aligning, hiring and retaining talent—remains the same. A glossary of these instruments is provided in the appendix.
---
Bottom Line
Index’s research shows that Europe’s next generation of global tech champions will succeed faster if they *share the upside* with employees. The handbook—grounded in data, lived experience and country‑level policy analysis—offers founders a concrete blueprint to make that happen.